本文已被:浏览 733次 下载 2166次
Received:August 11, 2021 Revised:September 13, 2021
Received:August 11, 2021 Revised:September 13, 2021
中文摘要: 人工智能的发展为传统的标书评估方法的优化和改进提供了新的方法, 针对标书评估中人工评标效率低和难以有效识别围标、串标行为的问题, 本文提出了一种基于文本分析的标书综合评估模型, 包含文本评估模型和文本评级模型, 模型为更客观、科学、智能化地进行工程建设项目的评标和防范围标、串标提供支持. 首先, 构建文本评估模型, 在传统的评标指标中加入基于Shingling算法计算的投标文件的重复率, 并将投标文件要求的模板目录与真实目录进行匹配对比计算投标文件的响应程度, 利用层次分析法计算文本评估指标的权重. 然后, 构建文本评级模型, 基于权重改进的Simhash算法计算投标文件相似度, 采用企业关联度、资质与报价的一致性、价格上(下)浮率、企业关联度、异常行为等评级指标, 通过综合评级获得投标文件的评级结果, 协助评标专家识别围标、串标行为. 最后, 通过文本评估模型定量计算得到标书得分排序, 通过文本评级模型定性分析得到标书识别围标、串标的结果, 两者共同实现了对标书的综合评估.
Abstract:The development of artificial intelligence provides a new tool for the optimization and improvement of traditional bid evaluation methods. To tackle the problems of low manual bid evaluation efficiency and difficulty in identifying bidding collusion, this study proposes a comprehensive evaluation model for bid documents based on text analysis, including a text evaluation model and a text rating model. The proposed model can provide support for a more objective, scientific, and intelligent bid evaluation of construction projects and the prevention of bidding collusion. First, a text evaluation model is built. The repetition rate of bid documents calculated by the Shingling algorithm is added to traditional bid evaluation indicators. Then, the template catalog required by the bid documents is compared with the real catalog for the calculation of the response level of the bid documents. The analytic hierarchy process is employed to determine the weight of the text evaluation index. Next, a text rating model is built. The similarity between bid documents is calculated by the weight-improved Simhash algorithm. The comprehensive rating is performed with corporate relevance, consistency between qualifications and quotations, price floating, abnormal behavior, etc. as rating indicators. The rating results of bid documents are helpful for bid evaluation experts to identify bidding collusion. Finally, a quantitative calculation is conducted with the text evaluation model to yield the bid score ranking, and a qualitative analysis is made with the text rating model to present the results of identifying bidding collusion. Taken together, the two realize the comprehensive evaluation of bid documents.
文章编号: 中图分类号: 文献标志码:
基金项目:
Author Name | Affiliation | |
REN Jie | China National Water Resources & Electric Power Materials & Equipment Co. Ltd., Beijing 100043, China | renjie@cweme.com |
Author Name | Affiliation | |
REN Jie | China National Water Resources & Electric Power Materials & Equipment Co. Ltd., Beijing 100043, China | renjie@cweme.com |
引用文本:
任杰.基于文本分析的标书综合评估模型.计算机系统应用,2022,31(6):149-157
REN Jie.Comprehensive Evaluation Model of Bidding Documents Based on Text Analysis.COMPUTER SYSTEMS APPLICATIONS,2022,31(6):149-157
任杰.基于文本分析的标书综合评估模型.计算机系统应用,2022,31(6):149-157
REN Jie.Comprehensive Evaluation Model of Bidding Documents Based on Text Analysis.COMPUTER SYSTEMS APPLICATIONS,2022,31(6):149-157